Is the Sex Offender Registry Fair?
Is the Sex Offender Registry Fair?
The 1990s saw a significant rise in horrific sex offenses directed towards children, prompting the federal and state governments to formulate laws to help deter offenders and ensure public safety. One of these laws was the 1994 Jacob Wetterling Crimes Against Children and Sexually Violent Offender Registration Act, requiring convicted offenders to register with their local law enforcement after their release from prison.In 1996, Congress passed Meghan’s Law (a subsection of the Jacob Wetterling Act), which was then signed into law by President Bill Clinton. This law required law enforcement agencies to publicize the information of convicted sex offenders. This meant that any person needing to look up a person's name when doing a background check for sex offenses could find their name in the sex offenders register if they had had a sex crimes conviction. Under some jurisdictions, the police must conduct community notification in neighborhoods where convicted sex offenders live.The intentions of the creators of sex offenders' registry were considered noble. However, in recent years, sex registry laws have come under much criticism from proponents of criminal justice reform and human rights watch groups as unfair and ineffective in attaining the initial objective. Additionally, sex offenses are the only crimes where offenders suffer double jeopardy for their crimes, which is unfair.Sex Offender Registration RequirementsAll states across America have laws requiring sex offenders to register with their local law enforcement agencies upon release from statutory confinement.While these laws may differ from one state to another, they have some basic similarities in their requirements. For example, some of the information required in offender registration include:
Name and aliases
Date of birth
Physical description
Internet identifiers and email addresses
Telephone numbers
Social security number
Residence
Employment information
The area the sex offender lived during the commission of the crime.
Professional licenses
School information if the offender is a student
Text of the offense for which they are registering
Vehicle registration information
Current photograph
Fingerprints, palm prints, and DNA
Sexual Act/Sexual Contact Offenses: Sexual acts offenses include most sexual assaults that involve any degree of genital, anal or oral penetration, which are classified in many jurisdictions as first degree criminal sexual conduct and third degree criminal sexual conduct. On the other hand, contact offenses involve unwanted touching of another person's intimate parts or the clothing covering those parts, which are classified in many jurisdictions as second and fourth degree criminal sexual conduct.
Specified Offenses Against Minors: SORA § 111(7) lists specific crimes against minors that require registration. Some of these offenses include:
Kidnapping or holding a minor against their will (false imprisonment)
Sexual solicitation of a minor
Using a minor to perform a sexual act
Solicitation of a minor for prostitution
Video voyeurism involving minors
Possession, distribution, and production of child pornography
Internet-based criminal sexual conduct involving a minor
Conduct that is by nature a sex offense against a minor
Taking nude pictures of oneself – Any person under the age of 18 can face possession of child pornography charges for taking nudes of themselves upon arrest. What's more, they may also be charged with distribution if they decide to share their nudes with friends. Upon conviction, such individuals may have to register as sex offenders.
Urinating in public – Under some jurisdictions, urinating in public can result in an indecent exposure charge upon arrest by law enforcement personnel. Upon conviction, one may have to register as a sex offender.
Flashing or streaking – While somebody may flash their breasts or genitals jokingly or go streaking as a dare, they can be arrested and charged with indecent exposure, which may require registration upon conviction.
Consensual sex between teenagers – Almost everyone might agree that an adult engaging in sexual activity with a minor deserves punishment. Many don't know that two teenagers under the age of consent in their state can be charged with committing sex crimes, such as sexual assault involving a minor, which could lead to sex offender registration for both of them.
Incest – Sex between close family members is a crime in all states. Upon conviction, one may have to register as a sex offender.
Limitations on employment
Residency restrictions
Restriction on getting rental accommodation
Loss of privacy. The information required in registration must include where convicted sex offenders live, their names, place of work, and having to carry a sex offender card (special ID) depending.
Loss of child custody
Shattered reputation
Four teens sitting on bench in front of body of water; image by Sammie Vasquez, via Unsplash.com.
The offense they were convicted for no longer requires registration
They have completed their probation period
They were juvenile offenders during the commission of the offense
A conviction is overturned
About Nicole Blank Becker
Nicole Blank Becker of Blank Law, PC is a powerhouse in the field of law and is solely focused on sex crimes. Being the former Chief of the Sex Unit in Macomb County, Michigan, her unique skill set sets her apart from all other defense attorneys across the country.